Prepare a dental journal club critique

01 / WHAT TO TRY

Start with the right material.

Publisher description excerpt: “Use when the user asks to critique, peer-review, appraise, assess the credibility of, or evaluate the methodology, statistics,…” Source ↗

Suggested preparation

• A lawfully shareable full-text paper
• Study question
• Supplementary data, if available

These are Fieldwork’s preparation notes. Follow the source’s full input checklist for the specific task.

The intended handover

A structured appraisal with evidence limitations and discussion points.

This is a source-inspected starting point. Fieldwork has not run-tested this skill or measured time savings.

02 / CHECK THE FIT

Your platform. Your context.

Platforms

Claude · Codex · ChatGPT

Publisher documents Claude Code and Codex/Agent Skills setup. Product-specific tools and supporting files still need configuration. ChatGPT is a manual instruction/prompt adaptation only; no native plugin installation or publisher-tested ChatGPT execution is claimed.

Australian and worldwide use

Geography-neutral workflow. Set Australian spelling, AUD, dates and business context explicitly; local compliance is not supplied by this label.

Setup type: Instruction-led

No named business app was detected in the inspected instructions.

Dependencies

• Instruction-led workflow. Preserve any references bundled beside SKILL.md.

Public instructions do not imply free access to Claude, ChatGPT, paid apps, API usage or generation services.

03 / SET IT UP

Keep the complete workflow.

1. Open the source repository and download its complete ZIP, or clone it using the publisher’s instructions.
2. For a new Claude Code project installation, place the complete research-critic folder in .claude/skills/research-critic/. Preserve references and supporting files; do not overwrite an existing customized skill.
3. For a chat-only trial, attach the protocol and required references, state which resources are available, and ask Claude to follow the protocol. Chat-only use is not equivalent to installing the complete skill.

Pinned source snapshot; review publisher release and installation notes.

Replace the brackets and supply the required inputs. This prompt is Fieldwork’s example, not a tested guarantee or a replacement for installation.

Follow research-critic to appraise this dental paper for a journal club. State which parts of the full text you could read. Map claims to study evidence, identify methodological limits, and prepare discussion questions. Do not make patient-specific recommendations.